Multi-Level Marketing and Pyramid Selling - Nutritional Supplements Distributor
A company that distributes and sells nutritional supplements sought an advisory opinion in on whether its proposed multi-level marketingplan would raise concerns under the Competition Act.
The Competition Bureau provided a negative opinion on the basis that
the operator failed to make reasonable and timely disclosure of the earnings of
typical participants as required by Section 55(2) of the Act, and that the
plan appeared to constitute a scheme of pyramid selling as defined in section 55.1
of the Act.
All product sales were tied to participation in the marketing plan.
There was no provision in the marketing plan for sales to non-participants. Existing
participants sold products to new participants thereby enrolling the purchaser
as a new member. Compensation was paid to the existing participant for each
of these sales. There was no way to separate the membership from the product
purchase, and thus the plan offended both paragraphs 55.1(1)(a) and 55.1(1)(b)
of the Act.
Compensation was paid to the existing participants for the sale of
products, suggesting that the initial product purchase was not sold at cost,
nor was its purchase intended to facilitate sales. This is contrary to the
requirements in paragraph 55.1(1)(b) of the Act.
Furthermore, because of the direct link between these purchases and
enrollment in the plan, existing participants receive compensation for the
recruitment of new participants, offending paragraph 55.1(1)(a) of the
Act.
The Competition Bureau provided a negative opinion on
.
3098167
Share this page
To share this page, just select the social network of your choice: